Watching some of Terrence Malick’s films you see that
memorable cinematography and beauty are given special attention. But what and
why are some things considered so beautiful? The setting in “The Thin Red Line
(1998)” is wartime Vietnam and although much of the land is possessed by war,
it is impossible not to appreciate the superb scenery and awe-inspiring
landscape. The score also increases the sense of beauty that is expressed throughout
the film. So all I am curious about is why do I watch that film and recognize
some of the things I see in it as beautiful, especially one about a war that
took so many people’s lives.
What is
beauty? What is beautiful to a person is subjective, but the idea of beauty is
what I am interested in. Someone may find a spatula beautiful; though I may not
agree with him or her, beauty is still viewed by him or her. Just as what makes
people happy and sad differs, it is still understood that happiness, sadness,
and even beauty, though received from different things, is still interpreted in
relatively the same way. I’m happy when I’m happy and sad when I’m sad; to be
otherwise is to be in mental conundrum. So when something is considered
beautiful from what aspects of that thing am I deriving that beauty and are the
concepts of beauty that I find held within something shared amongst people?
This is
where I tend to get rather lost, especially since people derive beauty from so
many things. For instance, I know someone who enjoys watching videos of pimples
and cyst’s popping out puss. To me this is rather repulsive, but they enjoy watching
the release of such pressure and you could say they find beauty in it. I too
enjoy the release of pressure, but am too distracted by the puss to really
appreciate those videos. However, it is important to see that although I do not
enjoy the videos I do relate to the idea that pressure being released can be
enjoyable. For example, when I have a final, I become stressed (pressure builds
up) and when I finish taking that final I usually feel pretty relieved
(pressure is released). Even if the concept of pressure being released is not
considered beautiful, it makes me curious if there is some universal thought
about what beauty is. What makes a song or a poem touch you? Why does a scene from
a movie make you cry? Why is this scene
from "Tree of Life" so beautiful to me (and more importantly does it really need
to be in the movie)? If people could respond by sharing a scene from a movie
that they found beautiful and then explain why, I would love to gain some new
and fresh perspectives of beauty.
This is a great post and I am glad you took time to ask these questions regarding aesthetics. I too loved this scene from Tree of Life.
ReplyDeleteBeauty was a very popular topic for the Greeks, and the fibonacci number series and the golden mean are examples of a rational approach to understanding aesthetics. Aristotle also brought in the notion of catharsis as a tool for analyzing things that move us emotionally.
Other movies that explore such themes are American Beauty--the paper bag scene is quite amazing (though it has been often parodied)--http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yH_CfkNUC_g
What Dreams may Come has some amazing imagery and touching moments of understanding; the moment of escape in Shawshank Redemption; Tree of Life is amazing